Topic: The 2010 Gubernatorial Debate: An Evaluation

Darien Fenner

Date: 2010-04-19 22:48 EST
The following article was seen on page five through seven of the RhyDin Post, April the nineteenth.

The 2010 Gubernatorial Debate: An Evaluation April 19, 2010

http://i738.photobucket.com/albums/xx21/dfenner_photo/6264346944a710cfe80dc5.jpg Senior Columnist and Investigative Journalist: Darien Fenner

Ladies and gentlemen, apparently "farce" is the name of the game when it comes to government in RhyDin this term.

And when I say farce, I am by no means referring to James Madison's idea of government and information circulation when he said, "A popular government without popular information or the means of acquiring it, is but a prologue to a farce, or a tragedy, or perhaps both."

No. Nothing so insightful. When I say farce, I mean a government 'system of election' that some in RhyDin are beginning to consider nothing more than a topsy-turvy comedy of errors that occasionally pits some candidates against each other in a town hall.

An attendee of the 2010 Gubernatorial Debate this past Sunday was overheard making the following comment of the election itself:

"You know, I thought Jewell was nuts years ago when she said this was pointless, but I'm starting to agree in my old age."

And with candidates dropping out of the race for governor left and right for who-knows-why, who can possibly blame the constituent body for being a little bit cynical when it comes to politics" Perhaps cynical isn't even the right word for it.

But before we delve into the hyper critical aspects of what makes a good government or what attracts the public to voter's booths, let's try and look at what the 2010 election has to offer from an unbiased perspective.

Of the seven original candidates running, RhyDin's selection has been narrowed down to two. Silas Greyshott, Eleanor Legarde, and Thwei Cetanu were muscled out in the primaries, whittling the number of runners to four: Matthew Simon, Sheridan Driscol, Corlanthis Wystansayr, and Aaron Marshall.

Apparently, the stress of continually promising free booze was simply too much for Marshall, who not only neglected to attend the actual debate, but also announced his withdrawal from the running that evening, interrupting Simon's opening statement by proclaiming he was "like, quitting, yo' before bolting out of the Hall pursued by one of his assumed lackeys. Pardon. Groupies. Oh, apologies. This thesaurus is not particularly extensive. He was pursued by one of his assumed proponents. Here is to hoping that campaign funds weren't directly contributed to Marshall. If so, his constituents might want to reexamine the concept of a "free lunch' in a traditional, working economy.

That is what we do know, based on observation. Here is what you didn't know, as a public. Our reporters followed up with Marshall after he dropped out of the running. Here is what he had to say regarding his reasons to run in the first place:

"A lot think of my running as a simple joke on my part. After all, my campaign platform was entirely ludicrous. But truth be told, I was conducting a little test, you know" Like, I've become concerned with the people in this city; less and less does anyone seem to care much about anything but their own personal gain. It's <censored> crazy, yo. So, I thought: If I get past the preliminaries, there is absolutely no hope left for this city. And so, I ran. When I got it past the whole knock out voting, I was just like: This sucks. I can understand my friends voting for me, their friends, but the others" Dude. Not. Cool."

Perhaps the problem lies not with the candidates, but with the constituents" Then again, this was a man who seemed under the impression that free things equals money equals happiness.

Candidate Corlanthis Wystansayr at least managed to make it past the first question. It comes as no surprise that he submitted a quite diplomatic and well-spoken answer. After all, Wystansayr is a very capable orator, and performed extraordinarily well in the last two elections. The surprise, instead, was found in his abrupt withdrawal from the running following a query about the topic of slavery - A heated issue candidates were all-too-willing to get their hands on. Despite a solid answer, Wystansayr leapt off the stage and informally renounced his position in the race, instead seating himself with the rest of his constituents. Was his platform not solid enough to withstand the debate" Did he develop a sudden case of food poisoning" Obviously he didn't develop a rapid-onset case of stage fright. Exactly why would he withdraw, especially since his chances had been increased by almost twenty-five percent"

Here is what Wystansayr had to say when our reporters caught up with him:

"As I said at the debate, I won't compromise my values for the position. I cannot, will not, accept a position in which I must condone the practice of slavery. If that means trying to change things from outside the system before I run for Governor once again, then so be it, but I believe my decision was the right one."

Has that position changed in the last two years"

According to a few interviewed, they are shocked by Wystansayr's unusual behavior.

"I have voted for him faithfully each time he has run," claims a constituent. "I honestly can't believe he would so suddenly drop out like that. Who am I supposed to vote for, now?"

RhyDinians have begun express interest as to whom Wystansayr will endorse now that he has dropped out of the running.

Of the final two candidates, who will it be? Governor Matthew Algiers Simon, veteran to the gubernatorial office and first pick for duel-goers, or Sheridan "Dris" Driscol, luthier and self-proclaimed "friend" of RhyDin"

"Why you should vote for me is simple," explained Driscol in his opening statement. "It's time for a change, time for new ideas and new policies. It's time we stop pretending to be a community we are not and start embracing the diversity in which we are. Vote for me, and I'll promote what is instead of trying to change us into what we are not. This is RhyDin. It's time to remember that instead of pretending to be some other world in which we are not.?

Apparently, we are all under some strange sense of delusion, RhyDin. Our entire populace is suffering from some gruesome identity crisis! But don't look now - Driscol is here to help!

Continued on page six.

Darien Fenner

Date: 2010-04-19 22:49 EST
"The people are starting to forget who they are and what they are capable of by constantly suckling on the teat of deception," explained Driscol in an interview before the primary elections. "The average RhyDin citizen is a proud and self-sufficient animal who does not need to be rescued by a savior. No. What Rhy'Din needs is a supporter of all that already is."

Oh. Beg your pardon, RhyDin. Apparently he's not here to help. Just to 'support."

But how does he plan on promoting that kind of "unity," exactly'

?" My greater goal, my overall plan, to spread information," explained Driscol near the end of the debate. "As governor, I will not keep secret what I do, but keep the people informed, as many people as I possibly can, consistently. The more people know, the more likely they are to accept what is happening around them, especially if what is happening around them is beneficial to themselves and their society."

Perhaps we should reevaluate Madison's position. Reviewing RhyDin's resources and making information more easily accessible to the public is not only an excellent premise for a new government, but is also enormously helpful in pacifying the critics of politics - those who are adamant that nothing but dishonesty stems from bureaucracy.

So what kind of information is he planning on spreading"

"Registration. Citizenship registration, perhaps, to protect our citizens legally from the threat of being collared on a whim. Slaver registration, to regulate their practices. Something. Anything ....other than covering our eyes and pretending it does not exist, that it does not happen before our very eyes and we are, as is currently fact, powerless to stop it."

Hold on just one second, RhyDin! I've seen this somewhere before. Something about registration' something about demanding that RhyDin citizens forfeit their private information for the sake of having their names put on paper to be monitored"

"They are not the rulers of RhyDin; no one is," wrote Dib Jaster Aurene, Deputy Executive Officer of DeMuer Exports in September of last year regarding the proprietors of the Proposition 37 controversy. "Without their enforcers, they are an overly structured body of political essayists who hope people will think they have to obey whatever they put on paper. With their enforcers, they are warlords and thugs who plan to drag those of us who do not conform to their standards out of our homes and punish us however they see fit."

As suspicious as his theories on registration may seem, Driscol has strenuously assured the public that he had, in fact, voted NO on Proposition 37. Still, the argument he presented begs the question: Who will be the ones demanding the registration' And what penalties will be had for those who do not"

"Tell me where you can find a list of all the healers of this fair city in one complete volume," explained Driscol on healthcare. "And does this list include such things as what, specifically, these health care professionals may or may not specialize in" We must not disclude such specialists as the hedge wizards, shamans, priests and priestesses."

For a man brave enough to negatively name names in a publicized debate, Driscol certainly presents a foolhardy recommendation.

While it is incredibly unlikely that RhyDin's slavers and slave traders will have anything to do with registration of some kind, you cannot blame a man for trying, right"

Dr. Maranya Ergin-Falconne, Chief of Staff at the Riverview Clinic, argues that this so-called professional compilation toys dangerously with an invasion of privacy.

"Compiling the professional information on healers and other medical professionals into an easily accessible central directory is an idea that has been long overdue in its implementation, and I for one fully support it," said Ergin-Falconne. "However, compiling their personal information can be seen as an invasion of privacy, and I cannot in good conscience support that facet of the compilation effort. My personal lifestyle does not have any bearing on the quality of health care that I can provide."

The question remains" what exactly will go into these lists that Driscol is planning to publish"

Regardless of the particulars, information circulation is truly a novel and excellent idea. And suspicions and hiccups aside, Driscol would do well to drive home the details of this healthcare plan with the RhyDinians' rights in mind. The last thing citizens want is an invasion of privacy, especially in a town that has already so strenuously objected to having their names put on paper.

"I will say one thing," added an attendee of the debate on Sunday. "Driscol certainly talked circles around Simon. He is incredibly level-minded!"

For all the criticism of his particulars we have already addressed, it cannot be denied that Driscol certainly has a penchant for the oratory. His association with the average citizen puts him on the same level as his voters, and allows him to relate to them on a level that his opponents simply cannot. His familiarity with RhyDin's working class predisposes him to a certain sympathy that his constituents no doubt find attractive. And, despite occasionally polar views on certain topics, Driscol takes a deliberate, documented position, whether or not his constituents find it controversial. Perhaps making "friends" among the RhyDin folk is his strong suit, else he would not have ended up on that stage. One thing remains certain, however. RhyDin's government has, since its conception, been criticized as a farcical office devoid of any real attachment to the citizens it represents. And in such an arguably fragmented society, who is to say that a little more recognition or familiarity spread among the sum of RhyDin's bodies will not help instill a greater solidarity between men" Between species" Between worlds"

Here is to recognizing what is, for the sake of determining what will be.



Continued on page seven.

Darien Fenner

Date: 2010-04-19 22:52 EST
Hopefully Simon's popularity will reach Driscol's level, if it already hasn't.

"Sorry Governor Simon!" shouted a debate attendee as the ending arguments drew to a close. "I have no issue with you and I really like your wife but Dris lets me kiss him and you don't!"

?" Some of my fellow candidates are not taking this election, or you, Rhydin's citizens, at all seriously," argued Simon in his opening statement. "Over the last two years, I believe I've proven time and again that I am an effective Governor. I've put policies, methodologies, and ideas into practice successfully, in part because I approached each and every one with a solid plan, along with contingencies should things not unfold exactly as I hoped. Improvements to the Watch, the effectiveness of the RASG, the overall prosperity and positive improvements we've all seen citywide have taken place because I've worked both with you and for you. If elected again, I will continue to do what I've done. I will continue to make the development of this city and its growth and prosperity and your safety my top priorities. New ideas" are important....I am by no means saying that I have no new ideas nor that I will ignore new ideas or not consider something, as they say, new and unique. But, I caution that we should not abandon the proven path simply for the sake of trying something different. With ideas comes responsibility. With ideas comes the need to have a strategy to implement them. This city and everyone in it, including myself, has and should learn from the past, learn from our mistakes and our successes. We've had some of each the last two years, but far more accomplishments, triumphs, and positive improvements than we ever did in the years before the Governorship was established."

Simon's assessment of a responsible governorship in a nutshell for you there, ladies and gentlemen. I must admit, however, for a while I struggled to come up with an analysis of his particular policies. I couldn't pinpoint exactly what it was about that platform that seemed inconsistent or lacking, only that it seemed incredibly circuitous. But after some careful consideration, it becomes strikingly apparent that the problem with his platform is, in fact, that he doesn't have a platform at all.

Simon's arguments during the debate coasted on dated promises and vague inclinations, as a professional politician is wont to exploit. The general argument he presents is merely that he is more experienced than his fellow candidates, and therefore more qualified to retain his gubernatorial position.

"This election, the Governorship as a whole, it's not about offering something new for newness' sake," explained Simon in an interview prior to the primary elections. "It's about offering the best most adept leadership. It's about understanding of this city, of its people; it's about meeting with and learning with and from those people. It's about utilizing that knowledge to create plans and, more importantly, ways to capably and competently put those plans into action and meet the intended goals. I've proven I can do that; I've done it for the last two years. That may not be new, but it's what this city and its citizens need and deserve to continue to thrive and prosper."

Fair enough. Proposing something that is new only for the sake of having it proposed likely isn't the wisest course of action when it comes to the political playground. But banking solely on experience for experience's sake isn't entirely sound either.

Critics of Governor Simon describe his tendency to tiptoe around an actual platform:

"Matthew Simon has a nasty habit of pointing out the flaws in his opponents" arguments, while either presenting none of his own, or remaining deliberately vague on his positions," political analyst Richard Ewin explains. "Most of the time, that is an entirely effective plan of attack. After all, he puts all the negative attention on his fellow candidates, urging them to run the clock and get flustered, trying to explain why their ideas are better than his. This particular opponent, however, seems to have clued into this strategy. It's not about running the clock anymore."

As a rebuttal to Driscol's policy ideas on healthcare, Simon exhausted a lot of breath posing questions:

"So I'm clear, Mr. Driscol plans to take information already publically available, compile it into a new list, and call it an Awareness Program' Who will vette this list' Who will determine what qualifies someone as a healer, or an apothecary' " Spreading information is fine and well, but it's useless if that spread is not effective. What new information will Mr. Driscol's list provide Rhydin's citizens that they can't already easily access say, at the Rhydin Public Library or in their own homes" How will this new information be distributed?"

While Simon does, in fact, make an excellent point, note his tendency to downright interrogate his opponent, turning a single question rebuttal into a transparent monologue that not only rattles the opponent, but also inveighs against his platform by over-simplifying it.

He certainly has a way with words, doesn't he"

Coasting on his post-term policies has its benefits, no doubt, and Simon is quick to point out all the "right' things he has done with his governorship. Granted, RhyDin did not diminish until it exploded in flames and glory during his previous two terms, but when was the last time a public RASG report was filed" Where are the municipal statistics that say the crime rate has gone down as a result of Simon's new training program in the Watch' How do we know success is actually being had without any solid proof?

We will give him one thing: He undoubtedly recognizes the realities of his position.

"Whether someone chooses to acknowledge the existence of the Governorship, it does in fact exist. Decisions made by the Governor, by the staff, do indeed have an effect on this city and its citizens. As far as encouragement, if someone steadfastly refuses to acknowledge the position of Governor or it authority, all the encouragement in the world may not change . That's not to at all say the effort shouldn't be put forth, but my primary focus needs to be on the city as a whole, not trying to force people who don't want to acknowledge the Governorship to do so."

True, Simon does have experience on his side. And true, it seems his work in RhyDin has been (arguably) adequate in his past two terms. After all, we're still here, aren't we"

His policies seem solid, and he certainly seems about as verbose, educated, and combative as he was two years ago. Not to mention a large portion of constituents interviewed since the primaries have expressed satisfaction with Governor Simon's terms in office.

"I know for a fact that Governor Simon has done right by RhyDin so far," an attendee of the debate commented. "The good thing about Matt is that he is consistent. Dependable."

Certainly he is consistent. Perhaps even dependable. But is it enough"

You, RhyDin, get to make that decision. Transcripts of the debate itself will be published, and material on both candidates? platforms is readily available and waiting to be read and interpreted. The future of the governorship is in your hands.

Don't treat this election like a farce. Make your voices heard in government, and never be content with anything less than outstanding. Make an educated decision this April, and vote for the candidate you think most represents your views. After all, you are in charge of your decision. No one else can influence you.

Make your votes count. Polls close on the 25th.